Guidelines
Archiving Policy
IJRDO Publications provides the unquestionable digital archiving to maintain the long-term preservation and accessibility to all published content. Our publishing platform is used to ensure that all articles are securely stored and maintained, ensuring that they can always be accessed for scholarly purposes. The authors are allowed to place the final published version of their article in institutional repositories, in their personal web pages or in other recognized platforms, depending on the article, provided that they include the proper citation to the original publication. IJRDO is based on the principles of Open access and promotes wider dissemination of research with maintaining the integrity and permanency of the scholarly record.
We participate in
- LOCKSS
- CLOCKSS
- PKP Preservation Network (PKP|PN)
For decentralized, secure and permanent archiving.
Advertising Policy
IJRDO Journals strives to ensure the editorial independence, academic integrity and transparency in all its journals. All advertising and promotional material appearing on the IJRDO journal websites or publications should be clearly identified as advertising/promotional material. No part of the advertising shall affect the editorial quality, editorial peer-review, manuscript acceptance, publication or the selection of editors or peer-reviewers. The editorial work is done without reference to or dependency upon the other editorial staff members, and follows established journal policies and academic standards.
IJRDO Journals reserves the right to review, approve, reject, remove content that is misleading, inappropriate, unlawful, offensive and conflicting with the journal's academic or professional standards. The journal, the publisher, the editors or editorial board shall not be held responsible for the accuracy of any endorsement implied by advertising.
When advertising is allowed it will be displayed in a separate section from editorial material, thus keeping advertising separate from scholarly information. Advertising arrangements give no access or control to confidential manuscript information nor have an impact on the publication process to the advertiser.
IJRDO Journals may occasionally update its advertising policies as a part of keeping abreast of the ethical publishing principles and standards for responsible scholarly communication.
Peer Review Policy
IJRDO Publications is working on a policy of a double-blind peer review system where both the reviewers and authors are anonymous. This ensures that the manuscripts submitted are evaluated fairly, unbiasedly and objectively. The reviewers are expected to abide by the following guidelines and are of great value in ensuring that published research is of high quality and integrity.
Responsibility of the Reviewer
A reviewer should give critical consideration to a manuscript in his field of specialization and give honest, constructive and respectful comments. The review should clearly point out the strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript, suggest improvements and evaluate the originality, relevance and scientific contribution of the manuscript.
Initial Editorial Assessment
Manuscripts that fail to meet these requirements, fall outside the journal's scope, or raise significant academic or ethical concerns may be rejected without external review. Authors can normally expect an initial editorial decision within 1–2 weeks, depending on the journal and the complexity of the assessment. Preliminary corrections may be requested where appropriate.
External Peer Review
Manuscripts passing the initial assessment are normally evaluated by at least two independent reviewers with relevant subject expertise. Additional reviewers may be invited when necessary.
IJRDO follows a double-blind review system, under which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another as far as reasonably possible. Authors should avoid including identifying information in their manuscripts. The review process is generally expected to take 6–8 weeks from the date the manuscript is sent for review. Actual timelines may vary depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and other circumstances.
Editorial Decisions
The Editor-in-Chief or appropriately authorized editorial authority retains responsibility for the final decision.
Reviewers may recommend:
Accept
Suitable for publication, subject to any necessary editorial corrections.
Minor Revision
Requires limited corrections or clarification.
Major Revision
Requires substantial changes and may undergo further review.
Reject
Does not meet the journal's scholarly, ethical, or publication requirements.
Editors may request additional reviews or revisions before reaching a decision. All decisions are made in accordance with the journal's editorial policies and applicable ethical standards.
Reviewer Responsibilities and Guidelines
Reviewers are expected to provide fair, independent, objective, confidential, and constructive assessments. Their evaluation should focus on the manuscript's scholarly merits rather than the authors personally.
Reviewers should:
- Assess originality, relevance, methodology, evidence, and academic contribution.
- Identify significant methodological, conceptual, or interpretive concerns.
- Provide clear, specific, and constructive comments.
- Distinguish major and minor concerns where possible and explain their recommendations.
- Identify relevant ethical or publication-integrity concerns.
- Maintain professional, respectful, and unbiased communication.
- Decline invitations when the subject falls outside their expertise or a conflict of interest may compromise impartiality.
Reviews should be sufficiently detailed to help authors understand the required improvements. Where possible, comments should refer to relevant sections, pages, tables, figures, or line numbers.
Confidentiality and Privacy
All submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial discussions, and related materials must be treated as confidential. Information may only be shared with individuals authorized to participate in the editorial or review process.
Reviewers requiring assistance from another expert must obtain prior permission from the Editorial Office. Where instructed, reviewers should securely delete or destroy manuscript copies and confidential materials after completing their assessment.
Conflict of Interest
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest that could affect the impartiality of their assessment. Conflicts may arise from personal relationships, recent collaboration, institutional affiliations, financial interests, professional rivalry, or other circumstances that could create a risk of bias.
Reviewers should decline the invitation if a conflict could materially compromise their objectivity. Personal views concerning an author, institution, country, or research group must not influence the assessment.
Research and Publication Integrity
Reviewers should promptly notify the Editor of suspected:
- Plagiarism or substantial similarity with previously published work.
- Duplicate or simultaneous submission.
- Fabrication or falsification of data.
- Inappropriate image manipulation.
- Authorship or contributorship concerns.
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
- Research ethics or informed-consent violations, where applicable.
- Significant methodological deficiencies or other breaches of publication integrity.
The Editorial Office may seek further information, independent advice, or additional review to investigate such concerns.
Use of Artificial Intelligence
Due to the confidential nature of peer review, reviewers must not upload or disclose unpublished manuscripts, reviewer reports, or confidential manuscript information to publicly accessible generative AI systems or external AI tools unless expressly authorized by the journal.
Editorial Independence
Peer review provides independent expert advice to support editorial decision-making. No reviewer recommendation automatically determines the outcome of a submission.
The Editor-in-Chief or appropriately authorized editorial authority is responsible for ensuring that decisions are fair, consistent, and aligned with the journal's scope, editorial policies, and ethical standards.
Ethical Commitment and Enquiries
IJRDO is committed to maintaining confidentiality, impartiality, academic integrity, and responsible editorial decision-making throughout the peer review process. Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to uphold professional conduct, protect confidential information, disclose conflicts of interest, and comply with applicable research and publication ethics.
Note
Questions or concerns regarding peer review, reviewer conduct, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, research ethics, or publication integrity should be directed to the relevant IJRDO Editorial Office.
